Monday, November 3, 2014

Senate Race Predictions

SENATE RACE PREDICTIONS-
Underline= incumbent candidate

[Relatively] Undisputed Races:

MinnesotaMike McFadden (R) vs. Al Franken (D). Al Franken is going to win the senate election because he currently holds a 10 point lead over McFadden. Minnesota is a historically Democratic state and will remain so in this election.

"Election 2014 - Minnesota Senate - McFadden vs. Franken." RealClearPolitics -. Accessed November 3, 2014.

IllinoisJim Oberweis (R) vs. Dick Durban (D). Dick Durbin is going to win Illinois because his opponent has never been closer than 10 points behind him. His lead will remain strong enough to beat Oberweis in Illinois.

"Election 2014 - Illinois Senate - Oberweis vs. Durbin." RealClearPolitics -. Accessed November 3, 2014.

New JerseyJeff Bell (R) vs. Corey Booker (D). Booker will win NJ, he has held at least a 10 point lead over Bell, currently presiding over a 15 point lead. NJ is a Democratic leaning state and will remain so.

"Election 2014 - New Jersey Senate - Bell vs. Booker." RealClearPolitics -. Accessed November 3, 2014.

New MexicoAllen Weh (R) vs. Tom Udall (D). Udall is currently up 12 points in the polls, and although Real Clear Politics ranks this race on the watch list, I think this race is pretty clearly leaning towards Udall. Udall is above 10% and heavily favored to win. He will maintain this lead.

"Election 2014 - New Mexico Senate - Weh vs. Udall." RealClearPolitics -. Accessed November 3, 2014.

MississippiThad Cochran (R) vs. Travis Childers (D).
Thad Cochran defeated his first opponent in 1984 and since than he has won every re-election. Mississippians love Cochran and he has a 16 point lead. However, in a state with an incumbent of some 30 years, a 16 point lead is marginally small. Childers has been fairly successful at creating and maintaining an image of a very, very, moderate a democrat (a democrat moderate enough to represent a red state). Although it may appear that the relatively slim margins for an incumbent reflect that Missisipi is seeking a new face, I think that Cochran’s 16 point lead is easily strong enough to maintain itself until Tuesday.


 
Hampton, Paul. "The Sun Herald." With Conventional Wisdom on Vacation, Anything's Possible in Mississippi's Senate Race. Accessed November 3, 2014.
"Election 2014 - Mississippi Senate - Cochran vs. Childers." RealClearPolitics -. Accessed November 3, 2014.

West VirginiaShelley Moore Capito (R) vs. Natalie Tennant (D). Moore Capito is going to win West Virginia because West Virginia is a state characterized by Ballotopedia as becoming “increasingly conservative.” Capito currently holds a 22 point lead.

"United States Senate Elections in West Virginia, 2014." - Ballotpedia. Accessed November 3, 2014.

DelawareKevin Wade (R) vs. Chris Coons (D). Coons commands a 20 point lead in the polls. Coons is the incumbent candidate and Delaware is a historically democratic race, and will win the state.

"Election 2014 - Delaware Senate - Wade vs. Coons." RealClearPolitics -. Accessed November 3, 2014.

IdahoJim Risch (R) vs. Nels Mitchell (D). Risch, the incumbent candidate, commands nearly a 25-point lead. I think Risch will win-- Risch's odds for the current election are looking resoundingly, but not shockingly, strong in a state that strongly back Republicans (no Democrat has been elected to the Senate from Idaho since 1974, and a Democrat has been elected only once to the House since 1992).

"United States Senate Elections in Idaho, 2014." - Ballotpedia. Accessed November 3, 2014.
"Election 2014 - Idaho Senate - Risch vs. Mitchell." RealClearPolitics -. Accessed November 3, 2014.

MontanaSteve Daines (R) vs. Amanda Curtis (D). On average, Daines has commanded around a 20 point lead over Curtis. Real Clear Politics writes: “The Montana Senate race is simultaneously the subject of massive changes and overwhelming stability.” For, the incumbent senator, John Walsh, dropped his reelection bid in the midst of a plagiarism scandal. Thus, Daines instead faces Amanda Curtis. Curtis is a “fresh face” but her strongly left wing views, which are publicly and openly available on her YouTube account will likely cause her trouble in right wing Montana. Daines will maintain his lead and win over Amanda Curtis.

"Election 2014 - Montana Senate - Daines vs. Curtis." RealClearPolitics -. Accessed November 3, 2014.

South CarolinaLindsey Graham (R) vs. Brad Hutto (D). Graham holds a 15% lead in the polls. Graham has raised a massive $10,598,104 for this race, in comparison to Hutto’s mere $474,770 in comparison. This discrepancy in fundraising leads me to believe that Graham will maintain this lead until the elections in November.

"South Carolina Senate Race." Opensecrets RSS. Accessed November 02, 2014.

Special ElectionSouth CarolinaTim Scott (R) vs. Joyce Dickerson (D). In January 2013, Sen. DeMint resigned to head the Heritage Foundation. Governor Hayley appointed Tim Scott to serve the first two years of DeMint's term, and on November 4, 2014, the voters of South Carolina will elect a candidate for the remaining two years. Scott currently holds a 20 point lead over Dickerson. Governor Haley is projected to keep her spot in the governor’s mansion, as she holds a 16 point lead in the polls and is well over the crucial 50% mark. The approval of the governor who appointed Scott will help him maintain his seat for the rest of the term.


"Election 2014 - South Carolina Governor - Haley vs. Sheheen." RealClearPolitics -. Accessed November 02, 2014.
"United States Senate Special Election in South Carolina, 2014." - Ballotpedia. Accessed November 02, 2014.

TexasJohn Cornyn (R) vs. David Alameel (D). Cornyn commands a 22% lead over Alameel. Republicans have controlled the governorship for 20 straight years, and both Senate seats for 21. Republicans will continue to control Texas and Cornyn will maintain his lead.

"Election 2014 - Texas Senate - Cornyn vs. Alameel." RealClearPolitics -. Accessed November 02, 2014.

WyomingMike Enzi (R) vs. Charlie Hardy (D). Enzi holds a 38% lead over Hardy. That would be an extremely tough margin to beat. Enzi will win this seat.


"Election 2014 - Wyoming Senate - Enzi vs. Hardy." RealClearPolitics -. Accessed November 02, 2014.

Senate Races That Are Up For Grabs- It’s All About
Turn Out.

            In this year’s most disputed Senate races, it’s all about turn out. When the margin in the polls is small, the race becomes dependent upon who shows up on election day. This year, there are some common themes.
·      OBAMA?
o   Republicans are motivated by a distaste for Obama to come out and win that ever-important Republican majority
o   Even Democrats are dissatisfied with the job Obama is doing. As of October 26th, Gallup rates Obama with a 40% approval rate. How will the other 60% vote? Will they vote?
·      CONNECTION
o   Connection with the people—whichever candidate connects with the voters most effectively, will sustain a larger turn out, and gain the margin they need to win.

New HampshireScott Brown (R) vs. Jeanne Shaheen (D). The race between Scott Brown and incumbent Jeanne Shaheen is shockingly close. While most incumbents usually win reelection with moderate ease, Shaheen currently holds barely a two-point lead over Brown.  Brown characterizes Shaheen has being too in touch with the whims of the executive branch (most notably the president) and perhaps not in touch enough with the people of the state. Brown speaks about Shaheen: “Everyone in New Hampshire here was excited when she got elected and said she’d be an independent voice for New Hampshire. Unfortunately when she went to Washington she changed. She’s voting with the president 99 percent of the time and that’s not good for New Hampshire.” However, Shaheen can easily use a similar jibe against Brown. Shaheen reminds voters that Brown has been a senator in a different state, and has had a variety of other political ambitions and allegiances. Shaheen says: “He thought about running for the Senate again in Massachusetts, then he though about running for governor in Massachusetts. Then he went to Iowa and said he was thinking about running for president. Well, I don’t think New Hampshire is a consolation prize.” Both can be argued as out of touch with the people of the state, so it truly comes down to who decides to come out to vote.  Although Brown is a fresh face, I think that Shaheen’s incumbency will help to give voters the motivation to come out to vote for her, and giver her the win. A familiarly out of touch candidate is better than an new, unknown, breed of “out of touch.”

"Election 2014 - New Hampshire Senate - Brown vs. Shaheen." RealClearPolitics -. Accessed November 02, 2014.
O'Dowd, Peter. "In New Hampshire, Race For Senate Narrows." Here Now RSS. Accessed November 02, 2014.

KansasPat Roberts (R) vs. Greg Orman (I). Currently, Greg Orman has a 1 point edge over Pat Roberts. Kansas is a historically Republican state, so the question becomes why is an independent holding a lead (although a very, very, slim one) in the polls? It can be speculated that Orman assumed all of the Democratic votes lost when Dem. Chad Taylor dropped the race in September. In addition, Orman holds claim to all of the possible independent votes. However, in this race, more than any other it all comes down to turnout. Democrats may not turn out to vote because they may not be as motivated to take the time to vote for an independent candidate. However, it can be argued that because this race is so close, both parties will be ultra-motivated to make it to the polls, as the outcome of this race could very well define which party controls the senate. The Real Clear Politics average for Iowan Obama job approval is about 60%. This distaste for Obama will motivate Republican voters to vote to gain control of senate. Pat Roberts will win and Kansas will not become an independent state.

Blanton, Dana. "Fox News Poll: 1-point Margin in Iowa, Kansas and North Carolina Senate Races." Fox News. November 01, 2014. Accessed November 02, 2014.  
"Election Approval Rating - President Obama Job Approval in Kansas." RealClearPolitics -. Accessed November 02, 2014.
"Election 2014 - Kansas Senate - Roberts vs. Orman." RealClearPolitics -. Accessed November 02, 2014.

Kentucky Mitch McConnel (R) vs. Alison Lundergan Grimes (D). Although the race is very close in the polls, McConnel will win because of Kentucky’s history of disapproval of Obama (60 % of residents currently “approve” of Obama, according to the Huffington Post). In a year in which Obama's unpopularity has been used by Republicans across the country to bludgeon Democratic senators, Kentucky seems like the last place the party would have a chance to pick off a Republican incumbent, let alone the party's Senate leader. Nonetheless, much like the race in Kansas, a close race like this relies heavily on turn out, as both candidates remain under the all-important 50% mark. However, Real Clear Politics states that “National Democrats seem to be pulling the plug on Grimes' campaign. The fundamentals of the state are just too much for her to overcome.” Democrats would have to accomplish incredible turn out to have the pull in Kentucky to overcome a Republican incumbent.

"Kentucky: Obama Job Approval - Polls - HuffPost Pollster." The Huffington Post. Accessed November 02, 2014.
"Election 2014 - Kentucky Senate - McConnell vs. Grimes." RealClearPolitics -. Accessed November 02, 2014.

IowaJoni Ernst (R) vs. Bruce Braley (D). The race has been consistently pretty tight from the start although Braley initially commanded a lead, but Ernst currently commands a narrow 2 point lead, according to a Real Clear Politics average. Again, because Ernst holds such a thin lead, anything could happen, depending on who shows up to vote. In Iowa, it seems to have all come down to connects the most effectively with voters. However, another poll, a new “Des Moines Register Poll,” states that Ernst holds a 7 point lead over Braley, and has moved above the critical 50% threshold: “the poll shows Iowans think Ernst better represents their values” (Seitz-Wald). This is unsurprising due to Braley’s characterization throughout the campaign as being out of touch with Iowa farmers and common people. So, perhaps Ernst has connected with the voters enough to command the turn out necessary to win this state.

"Election 2014 - Iowa Senate - Ernst vs. Braley." RealClearPolitics -. Accessed November 02, 2014.
Seitz-Wald, Alex. "Iowa Senate Race Slipping Away from Democrats." Msnbc.com. November 01, 2014. Accessed November 02, 2014.

Our Predictions...Condensed:

STATE
REPUBLICAN CANDIDATE
DEMOCRATIC
CANDIDATE
PREDICTION
Minnesota
Mike McFadden
Al Franken
Al Franken
Illinois
Jim Oberweis
Dick Durban
Dick Durban
New Jersey
Jeff Bell
Corey Booker
Corey Booker
New Mexico
Allen Weh
Tom Udall
Tom Udall
Mississippi
Thad Cochran
Travis Childers
Thad Cochran
West Virginia
Shelley Moore- Capito
Natalie Tennant
Shelley Moore-Capito
Delaware
Kevin Wade
Chris Coons
Chris Coons
Idaho
Jim Risch
Nels Mitchell
Jim Risch
Montana
Steve Daines
Amanda Curtis
Steve Daines
South Carolina
Lindsey Graham
Brad Hutto
Lindsey Graham
South Carolina
(Special Election)
Tim Scott
Joyce Dickerson
Tim Scott
Texas
John Cornyn
David Alameel
John Cornyn
Wyoming
Mike Enzi
Charlie Hardy
Mike Enzi
New Hampshire
Scott Brown
Jeanne Shaheen
Jeanne Shaheen
Kansas
Pat Roberts
Greg Orman (INDEPENDENT)
Pat Roberts
Kentucky
Mitch McConnel
Alison Lundgergan-Grimes
Mitch McConnel
Iowa
Joni Ernst
Bruce Braley
Joni Ernst

That’s 6 democrats to 11 Republicans. If our predictions are correct, then the GOP has a pretty good chance at winning control of the Senate.
What does that mean?
o   If they do their job well, will it be more likely that a Republican will win the 2016 presidential election?
o   Can we say goodbye to Obamacare?
o   How will a Republican congress affect foreign policy? (Defense Appropriations Bill) 
o   Will there be changes in immigration legislation?
If Republicans win, they are only winning by a slim margin, so how much can and will things really change?
I guess we’ll just have to wait and see.

BY: Will Delaney and Emily Morton 

No comments:

Post a Comment